While mystery podcasts share common ground with true crime podcasts in their exploration of the unknown and the quest for answers, they often diverge in focus. True crime podcasts typically delve into real-life cases, examining the facts, evidence, and often the darker aspects of human behavior. Conversely, mystery podcasts may explore fictional narratives or unsolved mysteries, allowing listeners to engage with thrilling stories and speculative scenarios. However, the line between true crime and mystery can blur, with some podcasts blending elements of both genres to create compelling content that keeps listeners on the edge of their seats.

Similarly, mystery podcasts also intersect with horror podcasts, particularly in their ability to evoke a sense of unease and intrigue. Both genres thrive on suspense, tension, and the exploration of the unknown. While horror podcasts may lean more towards supernatural elements and the macabre, mystery podcasts often incorporate elements of psychological suspense and intricate plot twists. Whether you’re drawn to the chilling tales of horror or the captivating enigmas of mystery, these podcasts offer a captivating journey into the realms of the unknown, where every episode promises an unforgettable experience.

The 76 Best Mystery Podcasts

Moriarty

Moriarty, a captivating mystery drama podcast penned by creator and executive producer Charles Kindinger, unfolds an enthralling narrative. Produced by Treefort Media and Audible, each episode immerses listeners in a gripping tale of intrigue and suspense. Season one, “The Devil’s Game,” debuted on July 7, 2022, while the equally riveting second season, “The Silent Order,” graced audiences on November 9, 2023, boasting an esteemed cast including Helen Mirren and Anya Chalotra. Delve into this reimagined Sherlock Holmes saga, where Moriarty, recast as an innocent fugitive framed for murder, challenges perceptions of good and evil.

The Night Time Podcast

Dive into the mysterious and unusual with The Night Time Podcast. Host Jordan Bonaparte explores a variety of true crime cases and paranormal phenomena, offering listeners a unique perspective on the mysteries of the night. With its engaging storytelling and thorough research, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by the unknown and the unexplained.

They Walk Among Us

Explore the dark underbelly of British crime with They Walk Among Us. Hosted by Benjamin and Rosie, this podcast delves into a variety of cases, from chilling murders to bizarre disappearances. With its meticulous research and captivating storytelling, it offers listeners a glimpse into the sinister side of humanity and the mysteries that lie just beneath the surface.

Acast and the Law and Crime Network have adapted They Walk Among Us to the United States with their show They Walk Among America. So, it is always very settling to know that these type of mysteries aren’t limited to the UK. They could be right next door!

Morbid: A True Crime Podcast

Join hosts Alaina and Ashleigh as they delve into the world of true crime on Morbid A True Crime Podcast. With their irreverent humor and thorough research, they explore a variety of cases, from high-profile murders to lesser-known mysteries. With new episodes released regularly, it’s the perfect choice for true crime enthusiasts craving fresh stories and engaging discussions.

Crime Beat

Step into the shoes of Crime Reporter Nancy Hixt on her immersive podcast journey through Canada’s most notorious criminal cases. Over two decades, Hixt has traversed the streets of her hometown, Calgary, navigating crime scenes and uncovering the untold details behind headline-grabbing stories.

Winner of the prestigious 2020 & 2023 Edward R. Murrow Award (RTDNA), each episode offers listeners an insider’s perspective, revealing insights and revelations not covered in the mainstream news. Prepare for a riveting exploration of true crime like never before.

Finding Drago | Finding Desperado

Why would anyone write a novel about Ivan Drago. Yeah, the bad guy from Rocky. I like when mystery podcasts step outside the paranormal and murder genre and wade into such heady subjects. I mean, that question is a genuine mystery.

Embark on a fresh investigative journey with Finding Desperado, the latest mystery podcast from comedians Alexei Toliopoulos and Cameron James, renowned for their acclaimed 2018 series, Finding Drago. As Australia’s foremost pop culture detectives, they delve into the peculiar case of a bizarre Guinness World Record held by an enigmatic European aristocrat in 2005. Uncovering layers of deception, they unravel a web of intrigue, questioning the authenticity of this peculiar record in a captivating narrative.

Missing in Alaska

Explore the mysteries of the Last Frontier with Missing in Alaska. Hosts John and Scott delve into the strange disappearances and unexplained phenomena that haunt the Alaskan wilderness.

Telling the story of the two Congressmen whose plane disappeared in 1972 without anything resembling a trace. To this day, in 2024, nothing has turned up. No sign of the men. No sign of the plane. Creepy.

With their adventurous spirit and thorough investigations, they shed light on the mysteries that continue to baffle investigators and families alike.

The Generation Why Podcast

Join hosts Aaron and Justin on The Generation Why Podcast as they explore a variety of true crime cases and mysteries.

With their thoughtful analysis and engaging discussions, they offer listeners a fresh perspective on some of the most perplexing cases in history. From unsolved murders to bizarre disappearances, each episode offers a deep dive into the world of true crime.

A podcast that has been going strong since 2012, Generation Why doesn’t show any signs of slowing down.

The Conspirators

Dive into the shadows of history with The Conspirators, a gripping dark history podcast hosted by Nate Hale, a fictional enigma. Delve into the untold tales of intrigue and mystery, exploring the darkest chapters of human history.

With each episode, Hale guides listeners through obscure and enigmatic moments, shedding light on the hidden truths obscured by time. Prepare for a journey into the depths of the past, where secrets lurk and mysteries abound.

My Favorite Murder

Murder can be funny, right? Am I right about that?

Join hosts Karen and Georgia on My Favorite Murder as they delve into the world of true crime with humor and wit. With their irreverent take on some of the most infamous cases in history, they offer listeners a fresh perspective on the darker side of humanity. From high-profile murders to obscure mysteries, each episode is a captivating journey into the world of true crime.

The Truth About True Crime with Amanda Knox

Join Amanda Knox in uncovering the truth behind infamous cases. This podcast offers a unique perspective on true crime stories, including high-profile cases like Amanda’s own. Through deep dives and insightful discussions, it sheds light on the complexities of the justice system and human nature, making it a compelling listen for anyone fascinated by crime mysteries and legal proceedings.

This one is a little older, but it stands the test of time. You know, because the stories already happened. That’s nice thing with podcasts about history. The don’t have to be the freshest.

The Strange and Unusual Podcast

Step into the realm of the bizarre with The Strange and Unusual Podcast. This captivating series explores a variety of mysteries, from supernatural occurrences to historical oddities. With its blend of storytelling and in-depth research, it transports listeners to the fringes of reality, making it a perfect choice for those intrigued by the unexplained and the mysterious.

RedHanded

For a fresh take on true crime, tune in to RedHanded.

As an aside, they seem to produce a disproportionate number of mystery podcasts for such a small country. What’s going on there? A mystery unto itself. Perhaps we will investigate.

This British podcast dives deep into a wide range of cases, from chilling murders to shocking scandals. With its engaging hosts and thorough investigations, it offers a compelling mix of storytelling and analysis, keeping listeners hooked from start to finish. Perfect for true crime enthusiasts craving new episodes filled with intrigue and suspense.

LISK: Long Island Serial Killer

Delve into the chilling mystery surrounding the Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) with this compelling podcast brought to you by Mopac Audio, a subsidiary of the renowned Megalomedia production company. Hosted by writer and producer Chris Mass and his dedicated team, this series offers rare interviews, new leads, and incisive analysis inspired by the New York Times bestseller “Lost Girls” by Robert Kolker. With six gripping episodes and bonus content, uncover the truth behind this notorious case that shook the nation.

The Angel of Vine

Step into the shadows of Hollywood’s greatest unsolved murder mystery with “Angel of Vine,” a captivating fiction audio drama podcast that intertwines present-day journalism with 1950s noir. Follow a present-day journalist as they uncover the long-forgotten audio tapes of a private eye who cracked the case but kept it hidden. Featuring a star-studded cast including Joe Manganiello, Alfred Molina, and Constance Zimmer, this gripping tale of intrigue and deception will keep you on the edge of your seat until the very end.

The Apex & The Abyss

Explore the depths of human behavior with The Apex & The Abyss. This podcast delves into the minds of criminals and the mysteries of unsolved cases, offering listeners a glimpse into the darker side of humanity. With its thought-provoking discussions and gripping storytelling, it’s the perfect choice for anyone fascinated by true crime stories and psychological thrillers.

Hunting Warhead

Embark on a harrowing journey with Hunting Warhead, a gripping true crime podcast that exposes the darkest corners of the internet. Host Daemon Fairless leads listeners through a global mission to dismantle a criminal network and rescue child abuse victims. With shocking revelations and in-depth investigations, this co-production of CBC Podcasts and the Norwegian newspaper VG sheds light on the sinister underbelly of cyberspace. Prepare to be captivated by the bravery of journalists and police as they confront the horrors hidden in the shadows.

Last Seen

Prepare for an enthralling journey into the unknown with WBUR’s ‘Last Seen’ podcast. In its third season, listeners are treated to a captivating exploration of mysteries ranging from a tragic homicide in Boston’s Haitian community to the search for a real-life Willy Wonka in Cambridge. With each episode, public radio storytellers unravel surprising tales of people, places, and things that have vanished without a trace. Don’t miss the latest episode, ‘The Gun Machine’, delving into America’s complex relationship with the gun industry.

Court Junkie

For an insider’s look at the legal system, don’t miss Court Junkie. This podcast takes listeners behind the scenes of high-profile trials and courtroom dramas, offering a firsthand perspective on justice and crime. With its in-depth analysis and compelling storytelling, it provides a captivating glimpse into the complexities of the legal process, making it a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts and legal buffs alike.

Missing & Murdered

Join the search for answers with Missing & Murdered. This podcast investigates cases of missing persons and unsolved murders, shedding light on forgotten victims and overlooked mysteries. With its empathetic approach and thorough investigations, it gives a voice to those who have been silenced by crime, making it a powerful listen for anyone interested in true crime stories and the pursuit of justice.

Red Meat Village

Experience the sinister side of small-town life with Red Meat Village. This podcast unravels gripping tales of crime and deception, exploring the mysteries hidden beneath the surface of rural America. With its focus on true crime stories and deep dives into cold cases, it offers listeners a captivating glimpse into the heart of darkness.

Deadly Manners

Step into a world of intrigue and deception with Deadly Manners. This scripted podcast delivers a thrilling narrative filled with twists and turns, reminiscent of classic whodunit mysteries. Set against the backdrop of a high society dinner party, it unravels the secrets of the wealthy elite and the deadly consequences of their actions.

Real Crime Profile

Join the experts at Real Crime Profile for insightful discussions on true crime cases. This podcast offers a deep dive into the psychology of criminals and the intricacies of criminal investigations, providing listeners with a nuanced understanding of high-profile cases. With its focus on true crime stories and in-depth analysis, it’s a must-listen for anyone fascinated by the criminal mind.

The Vanished Podcast

Explore the mysteries of missing persons cases with The Vanished Podcast. This compelling series sheds light on disappearances that have gone cold over time, giving a voice to the forgotten and the overlooked. Through thorough investigations and empathetic storytelling, it offers listeners a glimpse into the heartache of those left behind and the relentless search for answers.

True Crime All The Time

For a comprehensive look at true crime stories, tune in to True Crime All The Time. This podcast covers a wide range of cases, from chilling murders to perplexing mysteries, offering listeners a deep dive into the world of crime. With its engaging hosts and thorough research, it’s the perfect choice for anyone craving new episodes filled with suspense and intrigue.

If you’re looking for mystery podcasts that don’t offer any conclusions, and leave nothing but questions, the True Crime Unsolved edition may be your jam.

The Girl in the Blue Mustang

Join renowned journalist Keith Morrison as he unravels the perplexing case of Michelle O’Keefe in Dateline’s latest original podcast series, “The Girl in the Blue Mustang.” Set in California’s High Desert, this gripping tale of murder and mystery takes listeners on a journey filled with unexpected twists and turns. With each episode, Morrison delves deeper into the investigation, uncovering new clues and revelations that challenge everything we thought we knew about this tragic case. Tune in weekly for free episodes, or subscribe to Dateline Premium on Apple Podcasts for early access and ad-free listening.

Serial

Embark on a riveting journey into the heart of true crime with Serial. This groundbreaking podcast redefined the genre, captivating millions with its in-depth investigation into a single case. With its meticulous storytelling and gripping narrative, it’s a must-listen for anyone fascinated by cold cases, crime scenes, and the quest for justice.

Crime Junkie

Join the Crime Junkie team for thrilling true crime stories and captivating mysteries. This podcast delivers a mix of high-stakes cases and unsolved murders, keeping listeners on the edge of their seats with each episode. With its addictive storytelling and engaging hosts, it’s the ultimate choice for anyone seeking a deep dive into the world of crime.

Death in Ice Valley

Enter an enigma of an unidentified body in the compelling original podcast series by BBC World Service and NRK. For nearly half a century, the mystery of her identity has remained unsolved. Join investigators as they unravel the perplexing case, probing into the depths of history to uncover the truth behind this haunting tale. With meticulous research and gripping storytelling, this podcast promises to captivate listeners as it seeks to shed light on a decades-old mystery.

Dark Poutine

Enter into the darker side of Canadian history with Dark Poutine. This podcast explores chilling true crime stories and unsolved mysteries from across Canada, offering listeners a glimpse into the country’s shadowy past. With its focus on crime scene investigations and deep dives into cold cases, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by Canadian crime mysteries.

Missing on 9/11

Step back to September 10, 2001, one block from the World Trade Center, where security cameras capture the final moments of Dr. Sneha Anne Philip shopping. The following day, amidst chaos, Sneha vanishes without a trace. What befell Sneha? Join the team behind “Missing in Alaska” as they delve into this perplexing mystery, uncovering clues and confronting the unknown. Prepare for a riveting journey into the heart of one of New York’s most enduring unsolved cases.

Unsolved Mysteries

You know this show. It’s in your bones already. It’s a television juggernaut already. That voice. It just haunts you. Now it’s one of the premier mystery podcasts. How to tell its tale?

For a journey into the unknown, tune in to Unsolved Mysteries. This iconic series explores a wide range of perplexing cases, from cold cases to unexplained phenomena. With its captivating storytelling and immersive reenactments, it’s a must-listen for anyone intrigued by mysteries that defy explanation.

True Crime Garage

Yeah, that’s some cryptic Zodiac killer stuff. Do you think the symbolic communication was real? Could the cipher be real? Terrifying.

Pull into the True Crime Garage for a chilling exploration of true crime stories. This podcast dives deep into various cases, from high-profile murders to obscure mysteries, offering listeners a comprehensive look at the darker side of humanity. Its engaging hosts and thorough research make it the perfect choice for true crime enthusiasts craving new episodes filled with suspense and intrigue.

Missing Richard Simmons

If you’re a child of the 90s, then you know Sweating to the Oldies. This guy was a household staple. Daily. Like when Disney did Mousercize every morning on the Disney Channel. That was the worst way to start the day as a kid. Exercise? First thing?

Who was any of this for? Well… Richard cracked the code and then disappeared. What happened to this guy who labeled plain white socks with a left or a right marking? Then Pauly Shore enters the scene. Now we have a gigantic mystery afoot.

Embark on a captivating investigative journey with Missing Richard Simmons, a riveting journalism podcast created by Stitcher, First Look Media, and Pineapple Street Media. Hosted by journalist Dan Taberski, each episode peels back the layers of the sudden retirement of fitness icon Richard Simmons. Entering into Simmons’ mysterious disappearance from public life in 2014, Taberski unravels the enigma surrounding Simmons’ retreat from fame and explores the unanswered questions that linger in the wake of his absence.

Dark Topic

Step into the shadows with Dark Topic. This podcast enters into the depths of human depravity, exploring chilling true crime stories and unsolved mysteries. With its focus on crime scene investigations and deep dives into cold cases, it offers listeners a glimpse into the darkest corners of the human psyche.

True Crime Brewery

Raise a glass to True Crime Brewery, where true crime stories come to life. This podcast serves up a mix of chilling murders, mysterious disappearances, and perplexing mysteries, all with a side of craft beer reviews. With its unique blend of true crime storytelling and beer appreciation, it’s the ultimate choice for anyone seeking a fresh take on the genre.

Once Upon A Crime

For captivating true crime stories with a twist, look no further than Once Upon A Crime. This podcast explores a variety of cases, from historical crimes to modern-day mysteries, offering listeners a glimpse into the minds of criminals and the complexities of criminal investigations. With its engaging storytelling and thorough research, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by the darker side of humanity.

Lore

Step into the realm of folklore and legends with Lore, a captivating documentary podcast that explores historical events and ancient tales with a macabre twist. Created by Aaron Mahnke in 2015, each episode offers a campfire-like experience, drawing listeners into the dark side of human nature.

With themes ranging from chilling urban legends to historical atrocities, Mahnke meticulously researches each story, weaving together a tapestry of fact and folklore. The podcast’s success is evident, receiving accolades such as the iTunes “Best of 2015” Award and the “Best History Podcast” by the Academy of Podcasters. Lore’s popularity extends beyond the podcast realm, with a television adaptation and a trilogy of books authored by Mahnke.

Whether you’re a seasoned folklore enthusiast or a newcomer to the genre, Lore promises to captivate and enthrall with its tales of mystery and the unknown.

Lore was also adapted into a TV show on Amazon Prime and numerous books by Mahnke.

As an aside, is that the best use of that font ever? It’s solid.

MrBallen

Enter the world of MrBallen for riveting true crime stories with a twist. This podcast delivers a mix of chilling murders, mysterious disappearances, and perplexing mysteries, all with a side of captivating storytelling. With its engaging host and thorough research, it’s the perfect choice for anyone seeking a fresh take on the genre.

Crime Writers On…

Join the conversation with Crime Writers On… This podcast explores a wide range of crime mysteries, offering listeners thought-provoking discussions and engaging storytelling. With its focus on high-stakes cases and compelling analysis, it’s the ultimate choice for true crime enthusiasts craving in-depth insights into the criminal mind.

Unfound

Embark on a search for truth with Unfound. This podcast enters into the mysteries of missing persons cases, shedding light on disappearances that have gone cold over time. With its empathetic approach and thorough investigations, it gives a voice to those who have been silenced by crime, making it a powerful listen for anyone interested in true crime stories and the pursuit of justice.

Alice Isn’t Dead

Embark on a gripping fictional drama journey across America with a truck driver in search of her long-presumed dead wife in this thrilling podcast. Along the way, she confronts not-quite-human serial murderers, towns frozen in time, and a sprawling conspiracy that stretches far beyond the disappearance of one woman. With each episode, listeners are drawn deeper into a web of mystery and intrigue, where the line between reality and the supernatural blurs. Prepare for a riveting tale that will keep you on the edge of your seat until the very end.

Bone Valley

Dive into the gripping mystery of Michelle Schofield’s murder with Bone Valley, a groundbreaking podcast that unravels startling new evidence in this decades-old case. Host Gilbert King, Pulitzer Prize-winning author of “Devil in the Grove,” leads listeners on a journey to uncover the truth behind Michelle’s death and the wrongful conviction of her husband, Leo Schofield.

With each episode, King looks deeper into the shocking revelations, shedding light on a string of murders potentially linked to Jeremy Scott. Prepare to be captivated by this compelling tale of justice and redemption.

Ghost Tape

Enter the eerie world of “Ghost Tape,” where Tessa Dixon grapples with the harrowing experiences of basic training at a remote army base in Texas. When she stumbles upon a mysterious tape labeled ‘Ghost Tape’ belonging to her grandfather, Tessa unwittingly unleashes a malevolent force tied to her family’s dark past. Co-created by Nia DaCosta and Aron Eli Coleite, and starring Kiersey Clemons, this chilling audio drama podcast, written by Alexandra E Hartman and directed by Malakai, promises to keep listeners on the edge of their seats with its spine-tingling narrative.

Unexplained

Enter into the unexplained with Unexplained. This podcast explores a variety of mysteries and paranormal phenomena, offering listeners a glimpse into the mysteries of the universe. With its captivating storytelling and thought-provoking discussions, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by the unknown and the inexplicable.

Criminal

For captivating true crime stories, tune in to Criminal. This podcast delivers a mix of high-stakes cases and intriguing mysteries, all with a focus on the human stories behind the crimes. With its immersive storytelling and in-depth reporting, it’s the ultimate choice for anyone seeking new episodes filled with suspense and intrigue.

Vox does create some solid podcasts that you’d be hard-pressed to find better podcast execution. They aren’t indie podcasters by any stretch of the imagination, but they do good work.

Obscura: A True Crime Podcast

Step into the shadows with Obscura A True Crime Podcast. This series explores chilling true crime stories and unsolved mysteries, offering listeners a glimpse into the darker side of humanity. With its focus on crime scene investigations and deep dives into cold cases, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by the mysteries of the criminal mind.

Unexplained Mysteries

Enter into history’s most perplexing enigmas with Unexplained Mysteries, a captivating podcast that explores the world’s most compelling puzzles. From mysterious deaths to scientific anomalies and paranormal phenomena, each episode delves into the depths of the unknown, leaving no stone unturned in its quest for answers. If you’re intrigued by lingering questions and unsolved mysteries, Unexplained Mysteries offers a thrilling journey into the realms of the unexplained.

Limetown

Delve into the mystery of Limetown, a fictional investigative thriller podcast. Hosted by Lia Haddock, this podcast follows her journey to uncover the truth behind the disappearance of over 300 people from a small Tennessee town. With its immersive storytelling and eerie atmosphere, it’s a must-listen for fans of true crime stories and supernatural mysteries.

Casefile True Crime

Enter the world of true crime with Casefile True Crime. Hosted by an anonymous Australian narrator, this podcast explores a wide range of cases, from chilling murders to perplexing mysteries. With its meticulous research and compelling storytelling, it offers listeners a comprehensive look at some of the most notorious crimes in history.

The Dark Histories Podcast

Dive into the shadows with The Dark Histories Podcast. Hosted by Ben Cutmore, this podcast explores strange and unusual historical events, from mysterious disappearances to paranormal phenomena. With its in-depth research and engaging storytelling, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by the darker side of history.

The Trail Went Cold

Join host Robin Warder as he investigates cold cases and unsolved mysteries on The Trail Went Cold. With its meticulous analysis and attention to detail, this podcast offers listeners a compelling glimpse into the world of true crime. From disappearances to murders, each episode explores a different case, shedding light on the mysteries that continue to haunt investigators.

Small Town Dicks

Get a glimpse into the world of small-town crime with Small Town Dicks. Hosted by detectives Dan and Dave, along with actress Yeardley Smith, this podcast explores real-life cases from small communities across America. With its insider perspective and engaging storytelling, it offers listeners a unique look at the challenges and triumphs of investigating crime in rural areas.

CounterClock

Enter the enthralling investigation of CounterClock as host Delia D’Ambra unravels the perplexing case of Bruce Cucchiara’s murder in a New Orleans East parking lot in 2012. With more than a year of relentless inquiry, D’Ambra peels back layers of mystery surrounding Cucchiara’s life and the dark history of corruption and violence in the area. From allegations of setup to ties to organized crime, each revelation raises new questions about Cucchiara’s demise. As the investigation unfolds, listeners are drawn into a web of intrigue, left pondering who murdered Bruce, and why?

The Minds of Madness

Step into the minds of killers with The Minds of Madness. Hosted by Tyler Bell, this podcast explores the darkest corners of the human psyche, from notorious serial killers to chilling murders. With its in-depth interviews and psychological insights, it offers listeners a chilling glimpse into the world of true crime.

Trace Evidence

Join host Steven Pacheco as he investigates unsolved cases on Trace Evidence. From disappearances to murders, each episode delves into a different mystery, offering listeners a comprehensive look at the evidence and theories surrounding each case. With its thorough research and engaging storytelling, it’s the perfect choice for anyone intrigued by cold cases and true crime stories.

In the Dark

Explore the complexities of the criminal justice system with In the Dark. Hosted by Madeleine Baran, this podcast examines cases of wrongful conviction, miscarriages of justice, and unsolved crimes. With its in-depth reporting and groundbreaking investigations, it offers listeners a thought-provoking look at the flaws in the legal system and the human cost of wrongful convictions.

The Fall Line

Enter into the forgotten cases of marginalized communities with The Fall Line. Hosted by Brooke and Laurah, this podcast focuses on missing persons cases and unsolved murders, particularly those involving people of color. With its thorough research and empathetic storytelling, it sheds light on the often-overlooked victims and the systemic issues that contribute to their cases remaining unsolved.

The Murder Squad

Join retired detective Paul Holes and investigative journalist Billy Jensen on The Murder Squad as they dive into cold cases and unsolved murders. With their combined expertise and relentless pursuit of justice, they uncover new leads and reexamine old evidence, offering listeners a unique perspective on the cases they investigate. From high-profile mysteries to lesser-known crimes, The Murder Squad is a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts.

Mysterious Universe

Explore the strange and unexplained with Mysterious Universe. Hosted by Ben Grundy and Aaron Wright, this podcast covers a wide range of topics, from paranormal phenomena to conspiracy theories. With its engaging hosts and in-depth research, it offers listeners a thought-provoking look at the mysteries that defy explanation. Whether you’re interested in UFOs, cryptids, or the supernatural, Mysterious Universe has something for everyone.

Crime in Sports

Get ready for a dose of true crime and sports scandals with Crime in Sports. Hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, this podcast explores the darker side of the sports world, from athlete scandals to bizarre crimes committed by sports figures. With its irreverent humor and thorough research, it offers listeners a fresh perspective on the intersection of sports and true crime.

You know those balls were deflated. You know it. C’mon.

Your Own Backyard

Join the gripping investigation into the baffling disappearance of Cal Poly student Kristin Smart in 1996. This documentary podcast series digs deep into the mysterious circumstances surrounding Smart’s vanishing, exploring every lead and uncovering new revelations along the way. With meticulous research and compelling storytelling, listeners are taken on a journey to uncover the truth behind this decades-old cold case. Prepare to be captivated by the twists and turns of this haunting tale.

And a scant few years later… I nearly went to college there. Makes you think.

Unfound

Unfound, an established missing persons program since September 2016, is dedicated to shedding light on unsolved cases by interviewing those closest to the victims family, friends, and reporters. Hosted by Ed Dentzel, the podcast focuses on unearthing new leads to propel investigations forward. Dentzel’s commitment goes beyond the microphone as he works behind the scenes, offering support and guidance to families while tirelessly pursuing justice. With each episode, Unfound offers hope for resolution in the quest for answers.

Swindled

Enter into the dark world of white-collar crime and corporate greed with Swindled, an American true crime podcast hosted by the enigmatic “A Concerned Citizen.” Each meticulously crafted episode explores the depths of corruption and deception in a capitalist culture, shedding light on unsavory characters and their nefarious schemes. With a blend of archival audio, suspenseful scoring, and dry humor, Swindled delivers a gripping narrative that exposes the underbelly of society’s obsession with wealth. From prelude stories to compelling main subjects, this podcast is a riveting exploration of greed and its consequences.

True Crime Island

Take a trip to True Crime Island with host Cambo as he explores true crime stories from Australia and around the world. With his laid-back Aussie charm and extensive research, he brings listeners fascinating tales of murder, mystery, and mayhem. From notorious criminals to obscure cases, True Crime Island offers a unique perspective on the darker side of humanity.

And yeah, it’s another older one, but it stands up and the artwork fits the time.

Cold

Enter into the chilling case of Susan Powell’s disappearance with Cold. Hosted by journalist Dave Cawley, this podcast offers a comprehensive look at one of America’s most baffling cold cases. Through interviews, audio recordings, and meticulous research, Cold takes listeners on a journey into the heart of the investigation, shedding light on the complex web of lies and deceit surrounding Susan’s disappearance.

Hysteria 51

Join hosts Brent and John as they explore all things mysterious and bizarre on Hysteria 51. From conspiracy theories to paranormal phenomena, this podcast covers a wide range of topics with humor and wit. With its engaging hosts and thought-provoking discussions, Hysteria 51 is a must-listen for anyone intrigued by the unexplained and the unknown.

The Unresolved Podcast

Enter the world of cold cases and unsolved mysteries with The Unresolved Podcast. Hosted by Michael Whelan, this podcast enters into the details of some of the most perplexing cases in history. From disappearances to murders, each episode offers listeners a comprehensive look at the evidence and theories surrounding each case. With its thorough research and engaging storytelling, The Unresolved Podcast is a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts.

Camp Here & There

More classic weirdness!

Step into the eerie world of Camp Here & There, a weekly horror comedy podcast set in a quaint midwestern sleepaway camp besieged by supernatural phenomena and natural calamities. Sydney Sargent, the camp nurse, cheerfully narrates the unfolding horrors with an unsettling smile. Written and directed by Blue Mayfield and Nicholas Belov, the podcast features a talented ensemble cast and an original soundtrack by Will Wood and Jonathon Maisto. Brace yourself for a spine-chilling adventure that blurs the lines between humor and terror.

The Magnus Archives

Enter the world of horror and mystery with The Magnus Archives. Hosted by Jonathan Sims, this podcast presents a collection of supernatural tales, each more chilling than the last. From ghostly apparitions to eldritch horrors, each episode offers listeners a glimpse into the darker side of reality. With its immersive storytelling and eerie atmosphere, The Magnus Archives is a must-listen for fans of horror and mystery.

Up and Vanished

Join host Payne Lindsey as he investigates cold cases and missing persons cases on Up and Vanished. From disappearances to unsolved murders, each season of this podcast focuses on a different case, offering listeners a comprehensive look at the evidence and theories surrounding each one. With its immersive storytelling and investigative approach, Up and Vanished is a must-listen for anyone interested in true crime stories.

Someone Knows Something

Join host David Ridgen as he explores cold cases and missing persons cases on Someone Knows Something. With its empathetic approach and thorough investigations, this podcast offers listeners a unique perspective on some of the most baffling cases in history. From disappearances to unsolved murders, each episode sheds light on the mysteries that continue to haunt investigators and families alike.

Mystery Podcasts FAQ

What is the #1 rated true crime podcast?

The “#1 rated” true crime podcast can vary depending on different factors such as listener ratings, critical acclaim, and popularity. Some highly acclaimed true crime podcasts include Serial, My Favorite Murder, and Crime Junkie. It’s recommended to explore different podcasts and find the one that best suits your preferences and interests.

Does unsolved mysteries have a podcast?

Yes, Unsolved Mysteries does have a podcast. The podcast, based on the iconic television series, enters into a variety of unsolved mysteries, paranormal phenomena, and intriguing cases. It offers listeners the opportunity to explore these mysteries in more detail through audio storytelling.

What are some great podcasts?

There are numerous great podcasts across different genres, including true crime, mystery, comedy, and more. Some highly recommended podcasts include Serial, My Favorite Murder, Radiolab, and Lore, among others. It’s worth exploring different podcasts to find ones that resonate with your interests.

What are some good murder mystery podcasts?

Some good murder mystery podcasts include Casefile True Crime, Criminal, and The Trail Went Cold. These podcasts delve into real-life murder cases, providing detailed investigations, interviews, and analysis of the crimes.

What are the best mystery podcasts?

Some of the best mystery podcasts include The Magnus Archives, Limetown, and The Black Tapes. These podcasts offer captivating narratives, suspenseful storytelling, and intriguing mysteries for listeners to unravel.

What are the most popular mystery podcasts of 2023?

The most popular mystery podcasts of 2023 can vary depending on listener ratings, critical acclaim, and current trends. Some highly regarded mystery podcasts from recent years include Dirty John, Serial, and The Missing Cryptoqueen.

What are some mystery podcasts with a paranormal twist?

Mystery podcasts with a paranormal twist include Lore, The Black Tapes, and The NoSleep Podcast. These podcasts blend elements of mystery with supernatural phenomena, offering listeners chilling tales and eerie encounters.

What are the top-rated mystery podcasts currently available?

The top-rated mystery podcasts currently available encompass a range of styles and themes, catering to diverse tastes and interests. Some highly acclaimed mystery podcasts include Casefile True Crime, Criminal, and My Favorite Murder, each offering engaging storytelling and intriguing mysteries.

Which mystery podcast episodes are based on real-life cases?

Mystery podcast episodes based on real-life cases can be found in various podcasts such as Serial, Casefile True Crime, and Criminal. These podcasts meticulously research and present true crime cases, providing listeners with detailed accounts and investigations of real-life mysteries.

The post The 76 Best Mystery Podcasts to Pique Your Interest appeared first on Discover the Best Podcasts | Discover Pods.

And it’s not just for Halloween either. Good scary stories are always relevant. October isn’t the only spooky season.

When the United States Navy is confirming the existence of UFOs, when the United States Airforce is shooting down not only spy balloons, but who knows what, it’s time to take the paranormal seriously.

Well before paranormal podcasts, we grew up on shows like Unsolved Mysteries (that is even getting a reboot!) that would ask a lot of questions and wouldn’t provide too many answers. Remember the X Files? Yeah, we’ve been into this kind of thing for a very long time.

Why Paranormal Podcasts are the Perfect Medium

And yes, the “medium” pun was completely intentional.

Podcasts encourage the spirit of debate, and paranormal reports couldn’t be more suited. Skeptics and believers will argue about the existence of Bigfoot, UFOs, ghosts, and demonic presences until the end of time. Personal testimony and scientific research make the case for the validity of paranormal accounts. If you can’t believe it with your eyes, maybe you will with your ears.

Yeah, we tend to think of this type of thing during the spooky month of October, but the last time I checked demons and imps don’t use a calendar. This is an evergreen phenomenon.

Here’s a list of our favorite paranormal podcasts that will inform, frighten, tantalize, and entertain. 

This Paranormal Life

Award-winning podcast This Paranormal Life dives right into each episode with a rapid-fire intro, posing provocative questions that float atop the show’s eerie theme. “Is someone torturing a voodoo doll of me or do I just have back pain? Is ectoplasm good for you?” Hosts Rory Powers and Kit Grier open episode #142, disclosing their comedic slant while maintaining their investigative approach to alleged paranormal cases.  

Some of the best paranormal studies work being done in the podcast space.  

Most episodes clock in between 45min and an hour. This Paranormal Life gushes with passion in its engaging narration and light-hearted nature. Sound effects, pin-point comedic timing, and a lush soundtrack reward all fans of the paranormal.   

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify  

Weird Darkness: Stories of the Paranormal, Supernatural, Legends, Lore, Mysterious, Macabre, Unsolved

“Weird Darkness,” hosted by the engaging storyteller Darren Marlar, is a captivating podcast that delves into the mysterious, eerie, and unexplained corners of our world. With a focus on true stories of paranormal experiences, unsolved mysteries, and bizarre events, this podcast offers listeners a thrilling and spine-chilling auditory adventure.

Each episode of “Weird Darkness” masterfully combines suspense, intrigue, and storytelling to bring to life tales of haunted places, supernatural encounters, true crime, and urban legends. Darren Marlar’s compelling narration and meticulous research ensure that listeners are not only entertained but also informed about the lesser-known aspects of our world’s enigmatic history. Disappearances and conspiracy theories go hand in glove.

Perfect for fans of the paranormal, true crime aficionados, and those who enjoy exploring the shadowy side of human existence, “Weird Darkness” provides an immersive experience that will leave you questioning the boundaries of reality. So, gather your courage, dim the lights, and tune in to this enthralling podcast for a hauntingly unforgettable journey into the unknown.

Real Ghost Stories Online

Tony Brueski hosts this podcast and honestly, it’s terrifying. The premise is that Tony sources real-world ghost stories, supposed demonic possessions, and simply overall weird experiences.

And he’s talking about things I’ve actually experienced which made the hair on my neck stand up. Have you ever experienced sleep paralysis? Where you were awake, but you just couldn’t move? Well… talk to your doctor, but perhaps we were really dealing with something more… extraordinary going on?

Nobody wants to sound crazy, but what if this is real? It’s not bunch of horror stories, it’s life.

That’s what makes this podcast so good. It’s not fiction. It’s sourced from real-life events and those events are explained through a paranormal prism.

The NoSleep Podcast

The NoSleep Podcast embellishes the dark atmosphere of horror fiction with spooky music and theater to set the mood. The show aims to frighten and keep you up and night. Episodes can go up to three hours long and harken back to hearing tales around a campfire at midnight.

Professional voice-acting and narration present stories that range from hauntings and possessions to space dramas. Episode S8E23, “The Smiling Ones on Space Station Mir”, explores the mystery of a space station disappearing from orbit.

Stories are curated from volunteer writers on Reddit, and the voice actors do a great job bringing the chills of the written word to life, and death. Each episode contains stories focused on a specific topic. The NoSleep Podcast is a must-listen for fans of horror audio fiction.    

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Ghost Town

Jason Horton and Rebecca Leib’s playful banter induces laughter without mean-spirited insults. Ghost Town explores the occult and paranormal conspiracies. Rebecca’s experience as a haunted places tour guide allows the listener to live vicariously through her into the world of ghosts, demons, and possessions.

In Episode 72: The Haunted Roosevelt Hotel, Ghost Town recruits the help of psychic medium Linda Spellman to learn about the rich and chilling history of the hotel and its ghosts. It captures the podcast’s pursuit of the truth and willingness to confront fear.

Shows run between 30min and an hour along with mini-episodes to deliver releases twice a week. Listen to this show for an honest Ghost Adventures-like vibe without sensationalism.

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Blurry Photos

Blurry Photos investigates the fringes of the fringe with topics like the hollow moon theory, phantom time, and the Mirrored Men. Host David Flora explores oddities and phenomena that are lesser-known even amongst paranormal enthusiasts.

David Flora weighs the perspectives of believer and skeptic in his respect for guests and topics. He encourages the listener to have an open mind “before you lose faith” in Ep 209: Stigmata, showcasing his love for puns and the ability to remain neutral on controversial beliefs.

Blurry Photos is earnest in its research while maintaining a sense of humor in the presentation. Flora’s story-telling informs without being dry. His humility marries curiosity and authenticity. Episodes are typically between 30 minutes to an hour and a half, releasing one to three times a month. 

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Astonishing Legends

Hosts Scott Philbrook and Forrest Burgess connect with and interview people affected by paranormal experiences. The episodes bring a round-table approach to the conversations. Stories unfold with Scott and Forrest’s personal takeaways that ground supernatural phenomena.

Astonishing Legends embraces the long-form format with many episodes going for two to three or more hours. The sharp dialogue and discussion ensure shows don’t feel like they drag on. Episodes like The Grim Reaper and The Near-Death Experience Parts 1 and 2 satisfy an obsession with horror stories and the macabre, presented in a way that hits a little too close to home. Check in to Astonishing Legends to both soothe and exacerbate coming to terms with your own mortality.

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Mysterious Universe

Mysterious Universe draws inspiration from paranormal and conspiracy theory AM radio show Coast to Coast. Hosts Aaron Wright and Benjamin Grundy cover news of the strange and weird, UFOs and alternative history. They approach topics with heavy skepticism and don’t push their beliefs on the audience. Wright and Grundy concede to the absurdity of their fascinations and laugh as much as they inform.

Mysterious Universe’s well-researched episodes are typically between 1hr-1hr45min and offer a paid model with more content for dedicated fans. Episode 23.01 – Retrocausal Destiny highlights the show’s ability to uncover the niche-est of the niche, concluding that “Eventually someone’s going to make a robot Abraham Lincoln.”

Check out Mysterious Universe for a podcast that plays like a high-quality radio show.   

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Frightday

The dynamic between Byron, Sam, and Captain Kelly makes the show feel like a hang. They cover stories of the weird, supernatural, and morbid while maintaining an air of amusement and hilarity. They break the fourth wall of paranormal podcasts when they review films and drop references for true fans of the horror genre.

Frightday interacts with its audience with the occasional Q&A episode, like in Episode 200 when they discuss “The Shining.” Their fandom is authentic and their love for the paranormal is evident in their reviews. Frightday is shoulder-deep in the culture surrounding strange phenomena and horror.

Most shows are 1hr-1hr30min. Listen to Fright Day for a crew that matches your obsession with the genre.

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Last Podcast On The Left

The infectious enthusiasm of Last Podcast On The Left’s crew carries the show. Hosts Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, and Henry Zebrowski jockey for takes on topics that range from true crime small-town murder mysteries to haunted houses. Episodes come out weekly, ranging from one to two hours, in addition to side stories, providing a constant stream of content.

The hosts are heavy on the dark humor and wax inappropriate with their back and forth dialogue. If you dialed to this show on a radio, you might think you were listening to an uncensored sports commentary. While the hosts don’t hold back from offensive jokes, subjects are well-researched, like their study of Heaven’s Gate founder Marshall Applewhite in Episode 397, or their departure from humor with a serious take on the Columbine story.

Last Podcast On The Left will inform and entertain fans of both true crime and the paranormal. If you’re really interested in LPOTL, read our post on the best episodes of Last Podcast on the Left.        

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

The Cryptonauts Podcast

“It would be easier to measure what I didn’t drink last night,” Rob Morphy remarks at the beginning of Episode #113: The Ningen. He is joined by hosts Marc Storrs and Chris Carnicelli in a profanity-laced exploration of cryptids– creatures and animals that have been claimed to exist but never proven to exist.  

The Cryptonauts don’t take themselves too seriously, but the breadth and scope of mythical beasts and strange humanoids they cover intrigue and amuse. They don’t limit themselves to Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster. The Snallygaster, the Space Demons of Devil’s Swamp, and the Green Clawed Beast all lend themselves the show’s loose and curious outlook of paranormal wonders.

Most episodes are 45min to 1hr30min. Consider The Cryptonaut Podcast for expanding your knowledge of mysterious creatures.     

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Not Alone

Good cop Sam Frederickson, and bad cop Jason Moitoso pit believer versus skeptic with a dynamic that encourages civil discourse. The self-professed Magic: the Gathering nerds cover cryptids like The Wildman of China and contemporary paranormal events like The Miracle of the Sun. The phenomenon of The Miracle of the Sun, reported apparitions of the Virgin Mary in 1917 Portugal, is covered over four episodes and showcases the duo’s deep research.

Episodes are released on a weekly basis and are usually between 1hr to 1hr30min. The host’s camaraderie makes them accessible, relatable and easy to partake in their love of the mysterious and unexplained.

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | Spotify

Honorable Mentions:

These are podcasts that just missed the cut, and we’ll likely be coming back to explore them in more depth later. So, check them out, because you can never get enough of the weird and unexplained.

• The Magnus Archives
• Caustic Soda
• Unexplained
• All Day Paranormal
• And That’s Why We Drink
• Lore
• The Ectoplasm Show
• Those Conspiracy Guys
• Hysteria 51
• Cryptids

Why Paranormal Podcasts Are Amazing

There are a lot of unexplained phenomena going on. I’m going to say it again, the United States Government is admitting to UFOs. That means Tom DeLonge was right. That’s a hard thing for me to say. The guy from Blink-182 was correct about the government and UFOs.

If that’s not enough to pique your interest and make you completely uncomfortable, I don’t know what is. Let’s keep it light here in the close, but I’m hooked. Take a listen to these pods. Just be careful when you’re putting those earbuds in.

See you on the other side.

The post The 11 Best Paranormal Podcasts appeared first on Discover the Best Podcasts | Discover Pods.