Among these, true crime podcasts have emerged as one of the most popular and enduring genres, captivating audiences with real-life tales of mystery, intrigue, and, at times, unspeakable horror.

These statistics are a bit older, but newer data from the UK shows that the interest in the true crime drama has held steady.

Undoubtedly, the catalyst for the explosive growth of true crime podcasts was the groundbreaking series “Serial.” Launched in 2014, this investigative journalism podcast became a global sensation, reaching unprecedented popularity.

Hosted by Sarah Koenig, “Serial” delved into the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee, unfolding the story week by week, creating a narrative structure that left listeners eagerly anticipating each episode. This pioneering approach revolutionized storytelling within the podcasting sphere and established the true crime genre as a powerful and compelling medium.

The question often arises: why are true crime podcasts so popular? The answer lies in the intrinsic human fascination with mystery and the macabre. True crime podcasts allow listeners to immerse themselves in the intricacies of criminal investigations, offering a voyeuristic yet safe experience as they explore the minds of criminals and the dedicated efforts of law enforcement. The allure of solving unsolved mysteries and the adrenaline-inducing narratives provide an addictive blend of entertainment and intellectual engagement.

Regarding true crime podcasts, there’s a distinction between anthology and episodic formats. Anthology podcasts, like “Criminal” and “Sword & Scale,” explore a diverse range of standalone cases in each episode. On the other hand, episodic podcasts, exemplified by “My Favorite Murder” and “Casefile,” follow a consistent format with recurring hosts discussing different cases in each episode.

This diversity in storytelling approaches caters to the varied preferences of true crime enthusiasts, ensuring there’s something for every listener in the expansive world of crime podcasting. Popular podcasts like “Criminal,” “My Favorite Murder,” and “Casefile” have become cultural phenomena, setting the gold standard for the genre with their compelling narratives, meticulous research, and the unique perspectives they bring to the often-dark world of true crime.

Best True Crime Podcasts Of All Time

Serial

“Serial,” hosted by Sarah Koenig, revolutionized the podcasting world, offering an immersive, investigative journey into complex true crime cases. Koenig’s meticulous storytelling and unbiased exploration of Adnan Syed’s murder conviction captivate listeners, unraveling layers of intrigue and uncertainty. The podcast’s compelling narrative style, attention to detail, and ability to challenge assumptions make it a must-listen for anyone seeking a thought-provoking, emotionally charged, and meticulously crafted exploration of real-life mysteries.

As a spin-off of “This American Life,” Serial has become so popular that it has spawned its own production studio, producing more narrative podcasts that aren’t always true crime but are produced with the same rigor as the original. The group is still pushing the boundaries of the medium instead of just turning podcasting into YouTube fodder.

My Favorite Murder

“My Favorite Murder” is a true crime podcast with a unique blend of humor and empathy, hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. The hosts’ witty banter adds a refreshing touch to their exploration of heinous crimes, making the heavy subject matter more approachable. The duo’s genuine camaraderie and engaging storytelling style turn each episode into a captivating conversation. For those seeking a lighthearted yet respectful take on true crime, “My Favorite Murder” offers an enjoyable and compelling listening experience.

Casefile

“Casefile” is an enthralling true crime podcast that meticulously details complex criminal cases from around the world, narrated by an anonymous Australian host. Known for its thorough research and immersive storytelling, the show brings listeners into the heart of each investigation. With a chilling atmosphere and attention to detail, “Casefile” offers a gripping exploration of true crime, making it a compelling choice for those who appreciate in-depth examinations and a suspenseful narrative that unfolds with meticulous precision.

S Town

“S-Town,” produced by Serial and This American Life, transcends the typical true crime genre with its gripping exploration of a complex man named John B. McLemore and the mysterious events in his Alabama town. Host Brian Reed’s meticulous storytelling, genuine empathy, and unexpected twists create a narrative masterpiece. For true crime enthusiasts seeking a deeply human and introspective experience, “S-Town” offers a compelling and thought-provoking journey into the complexities of a small Southern community and the enigmatic life of its central figure.

Criminal

“Criminal” stands out in the true crime podcast genre for its succinct and well-crafted storytelling, narrated by Phoebe Judge. Each episode delves into unique and lesser-known criminal cases, revealing the diverse facets of human behavior and the criminal justice system. Judge’s compelling delivery and the show’s thoughtful exploration of both notorious and obscure cases make “Criminal” a must-listen. For those seeking a nuanced and well-researched perspective on crime, this podcast offers a captivating journey into the mysteries of the human experience.

One of the nice aspects of Criminal is that the stories tend to be shorter, making them ideal for commutes or walks through your scarier parks. You can get the entire experience without having to return again and again to the story.

Sword and Scale

“Sword and Scale” delves into the darkest corners of true crime, delivering a raw and unfiltered exploration of heinous acts. Hosted by Mike Boudet, the podcast skillfully combines audio from actual cases with insightful commentary, providing a chillingly immersive experience. While controversial, its uncensored approach appeals to true crime enthusiasts seeking an unflinching examination of criminal behavior. “Sword and Scale” offers a gripping, albeit intense, journey for listeners unafraid to confront the harrowing realities of the human psyche.

This podcast also focuses on the criminal justice system’s response to these crimes. Hence, the sword and scale title. The two items held by Lady justice atop the courthouse.

Crime Junkie

“Crime Junkie” captivates true crime aficionados with Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat’s dynamic storytelling and unwavering dedication to thorough research. The duo seamlessly blends suspenseful narration, immersive storytelling, and insightful analysis, creating an addictive listening experience. Each episode explores riveting cases, from missing persons to infamous crimes, fostering a sense of connection to the often heart-wrenching human stories behind the headlines. For those seeking a perfect balance of empathy, intrigue, and investigative detail, “Crime Junkie” delivers consistently engaging and compelling content.

True Crime Garage

“True Crime Garage” offers a distinctive true crime podcast experience, hosted by Nic and the Captain. With a laid-back, conversational style, the duo dives deep into intriguing cases, from unsolved mysteries to infamous crimes. The podcast’s charm lies in the hosts’ genuine curiosity and respectful approach to storytelling, creating an atmosphere where listeners feel like they’re part of an engaging discussion. For those who appreciate a relaxed yet thorough exploration of true crime, “True Crime Garage” provides an enjoyable and informative experience.

The Last Podcast On The Left

“The Last Podcast on the Left” uniquely blends humor with an in-depth exploration of the macabre, hosted by Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, and Henry Zebrowski. The trio’s comedic banter infuses a light-hearted touch into dark subject matter, covering true crime, conspiracy theories, and the supernatural. Listeners drawn to a comedic and irreverent take on disturbing topics will find the podcast’s approach both entertaining and informative. “The Last Podcast on the Left” provides a one-of-a-kind, edgy, and often hilarious perspective on the darker aspects of our world.

Dirty John

“Dirty John” is a gripping true crime podcast unraveling a harrowing tale of love, deception, and survival, hosted by Christopher Goffard. The podcast meticulously recounts the disturbing true story of John Meehan’s manipulation and deceit, exposing the complexities of toxic relationships. Goffard’s investigative journalism skillfully builds suspense, making each episode a compelling journey into the depths of a captivating and unsettling narrative. For those seeking a riveting exploration of true crime that delves into the psychology of manipulation, “Dirty John” is a must-listen. “Dirty John” was also adapted into a TV show.

Someone Knows Something

“Someone Knows Something” by David Ridgen is a poignant true crime podcast that brings listeners into the heart of unsolved cases, emphasizing human connections. Ridgen’s empathetic approach combines compelling storytelling with thorough investigative work, offering an intimate look into the lives affected by mysterious disappearances. The podcast’s dedication to shedding light on forgotten cases and its emotional resonance make it an enriching experience for those who appreciate true crime narratives grounded in empathy, compassion, and a quest for justice.

Dr. Death

“Dr. Death,” both the podcast and the TV adaptation, unveils the chilling true story of Dr. Christopher Duntsch, a charismatic neurosurgeon turned malevolent medical practitioner. Hosted by Laura Beil, the podcast meticulously investigates Duntsch’s devastating malpractice and the systemic failures that allowed him to continue harming patients. The compelling narrative serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of unchecked hubris and medical negligence, making it a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts intrigued by gripping and shocking real-life stories. “Dr. Death” is yet another example of a popular true crime podcast adapted for a tv series.

The Joe Rogan Experience 

“The Joe Rogan Experience” isn’t exclusively a true crime podcast, but Rogan often features compelling true crime episodes. He’s a little bit like Art Bell in that regard. And now that he’s no longer exclusively available behind Spotify’s paywall, there’s no better time to plumb the depths of the Joe Rogan Experience episode catalog. Aside from the true crime episodes, we recommend checking out some science episodes that can equally blow a mental fuse or two.

His relaxed interviewing style and diverse range of guests, including crime experts and investigators, provide unique insights into criminal cases. For those seeking a broader perspective on true crime with occasional deep dives, alongside Rogan’s signature humor and curiosity, “The Joe Rogan Experience” offers a captivating and well-rounded exploration of the darker aspects of human behavior.

The Generation Why Podcast

“The Generation Why Podcast,” hosted by Aaron and Justin, delivers insightful discussions on a variety of true crime and mystery cases. Their engaging banter, thorough research, and thoughtful analysis set the podcast apart. Focusing on stimulating critical thinking, they explore compelling cases, from unsolved mysteries to infamous crimes. For listeners seeking an intellectually stimulating and thought-provoking approach to true crime, “The Generation Why Podcast” offers an informative and captivating exploration into the complexities of criminal investigations.

Up and Vanished

“Up and Vanished” is a riveting true crime podcast hosted by Payne Lindsey that captivates audiences with its investigative storytelling. Focused on solving cold cases, particularly the disappearance of Tara Grinstead, Lindsey’s immersive approach combines interviews, evidence, and his own discoveries. Listeners are drawn into the unfolding mystery, experiencing the highs and lows of investigative journalism. For those seeking an emotionally charged journey into true crime and the pursuit of justice, “Up and Vanished” delivers a compelling narrative.

Criminal Minds

The “Criminal Minds” podcast, inspired by the TV show, offers an enthralling exploration of real-life criminal cases. The podcast is hosted by former FBI agents Jim Clemente and Lisa Zambetti and combines professional insights with captivating storytelling. With an emphasis on understanding criminal behavior, it provides an educational and gripping experience. This podcast offers a unique blend of expertise, storytelling, and real-world investigations for fans of crime-solving narratives and those intrigued by the psychology behind criminal minds.

RedHanded

“RedHanded” is a dynamic true crime podcast hosted by Suruthi and Hannah, offering a fresh perspective on infamous cases. The hosts infuse humor and genuine curiosity into their detailed explorations of crime stories, from historical mysteries to recent events. With a conversational style and in-depth research, they engage listeners in compelling narratives while maintaining sensitivity. For those seeking a balance of entertainment and insightful analysis in the true crime genre, “RedHanded” provides an engaging and unique listening experience.

Morbid: A True Crime Podcast

“Morbid: A True Crime Podcast,” hosted by Ash and Alaina, stands out for its blend of dark humor and thorough research into a variety of true crime cases. The hosts create a welcoming and conversational atmosphere, making complex cases more accessible. With a diverse range of topics, including unsolved mysteries and infamous crimes, the podcast offers an entertaining yet respectful exploration of the macabre. For those who appreciate humor alongside their true crime fix, “Morbid” provides an engaging and immersive experience.

The Murdaugh Murders

A century of power in this small region in the South Carolina countryside disappeared in a massive scandal. It was a case that, on its face, didn’t make sense. Why would this powerful attorney with more than 100 years of roots in the community murder his family so endlessly and recklessly? This podcast dives deep into the inner workings of Alex Murdaugh, making “The Murdaugh Murders” one of the best true crime podcasts to have come out in quite some time.

The Daily

“The Daily” may not be exclusively true crime, but its in-depth reporting often covers significant criminal cases and legal issues. Criminal activity by world leaders on a global scale is certainly in the spirit of the best true crime podcasts.

Hosted by Michael Barbaro, the podcast provides insightful daily analyses, expert interviews, and human perspectives on current events, including true crime stories that shape the news cycle. For those interested in a comprehensive and well-produced news source that delves into true crime aspects, “The Daily” offers a unique and informative take on the intersection of crime and current affairs.

Lore

“Lore” is a captivating true crime podcast hosted by Aaron Mahnke, seamlessly blending history and folklore to explore the darker aspects of human nature. Mahnke’s narrative skill and meticulous research reveal the roots of various superstitions and eerie tales, connecting them to real-life events. For true crime enthusiasts fascinated by the historical context and cultural origins of dark stories, “Lore” offers a unique and thought-provoking journey into the unsettling mysteries that have shaped our collective imagination.

Unresolved

“Unresolved” is a compelling true crime podcast hosted by Michael Whelan that meticulously examines cold cases, unsolved mysteries, and wrongful convictions. Whelan’s thorough research, compassionate storytelling, and dedication to shining a light on forgotten cases make each episode both informative and emotionally engaging. For true crime enthusiasts intrigued by the complexities of unresolved cases and the quest for justice, “Unresolved” provides a thought-provoking exploration into the mysteries that continue to elude closure.

MFM Minisodes

“MFM Minisodes” is an entertaining extension of the popular “My Favorite Murder” podcast, where hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark share shorter tales of true crime, listener stories, and personal anecdotes. Packed with humor and camaraderie, these minisodes offer a lighter yet still compelling dose of true crime content. For fans of the main podcast seeking quick, engaging narratives and a more relaxed tone, “MFM Minisodes” delivers bite-sized intrigue and the hosts’ signature wit.

The Murder of Mary Phagan

“The Murder of Mary Phagan” is a gripping true crime podcast hosted by Michael Whelan, delving into the notorious 1913 murder case that led to the lynching of Leo Frank. Whelan’s meticulous research, combined with immersive storytelling, transports listeners to a pivotal moment in American history. For true crime enthusiasts fascinated by historical criminal cases and the complexities of justice, this podcast offers a compelling and thought-provoking exploration of a century-old mystery with contemporary relevance.

The Vanished

“The Vanished” is an emotionally powerful true crime podcast hosted by Marissa Jones, dedicated to telling the stories of missing persons. With compassion and thorough investigative work, Jones sheds light on cases that often receive little attention. The podcast delves into the heart-wrenching experiences of families searching for their loved ones, providing a unique perspective on the human side of true crime. For those seeking a blend of empathy, advocacy, and gripping storytelling, “The Vanished” delivers an impactful listening experience.

Criminal Perspective

“Criminal Perspective” stands out in the true crime podcast landscape for its raw and unfiltered exploration of criminal minds, hosted by Chris Duett and Andrew Dodge. The hosts, along with guest experts, delve deep into the psychology of criminal behavior, offering a nuanced perspective on various cases. With a focus on understanding motives and forensic psychology, the podcast appeals to true crime enthusiasts intrigued by in-depth analyses and unflinching discussions surrounding the darker aspects of human nature.

All Killa No Filla

“All Killa No Filla” offers a refreshing take on true crime with comedians Rachel Fairburn and Kiri Pritchard-McLean. The hosts bring humor, camaraderie, and a unique blend of personal anecdotes to their discussions of infamous killers. Their engaging banter adds a lighter touch to the often dark subject matter, making the podcast appealing to true crime enthusiasts seeking an entertaining yet informative exploration of notorious criminals and their stories. For those who appreciate a humorous approach to true crime, this podcast delivers an enjoyable experience.

Real Crime Profile

“Real Crime Profile” offers a distinctive perspective on true crime with seasoned experts, including criminal profilers, behavioral analysts, and forensic scientists. Hosted by Jim Clemente, Laura Richards, and Lisa Zambetti, the podcast provides insightful discussions on high-profile criminal cases, emphasizing the psychological aspects of criminal behavior. For true crime enthusiasts seeking a deeper understanding of the human psyche behind infamous crimes, “Real Crime Profile” delivers expert analysis, engaging conversations, and a unique educational perspective.

This is really one you can end up going down the rabbit hole with on a binge.

Swindled

“Swindled” stands out in the true crime podcast genre for its focus on white-collar crimes and corporate scandals, hosted by A Concerned Citizen. The podcast exposes the dark underbelly of greed and corruption, delving into captivating stories of fraud, scams, and cover-ups. With a meticulous investigative approach and a no-nonsense delivery, “Swindled” provides a thought-provoking examination of the often overlooked criminal enterprises that affect society. For true crime enthusiasts interested in financial crimes and systemic wrongdoing, this podcast offers a compelling and eye-opening experience.

The Trail Went Cold

“The Trail Went Cold” is a true crime podcast hosted by Robin Warder, focusing on unsolved mysteries and cold cases. Warder’s thorough research, attention to detail, and empathetic storytelling breathe life into forgotten cases, exploring the myriad twists and turns of each investigation. For true crime enthusiasts intrigued by the complexities of unsolved mysteries and the quest for closure, “The Trail Went Cold” provides a compelling and immersive journey into the lingering mysteries that continue to evade resolution.

Criminal Broads

“Criminal Broads” offers a unique and refreshing perspective on true crime, hosted by Tori Telfer. Focused on exploring the lives and crimes of infamous women throughout history, Telfer combines humor, empathy, and thorough research in her storytelling. This podcast provides an engaging and informative experience for true crime enthusiasts who appreciate a diverse range of narratives, shedding light on the stories of compelling and often misunderstood female figures within the criminal landscape.

Canadian True Crime

Did you think crime happened in the great white north? I didn’t. Wow, was I wrong.

“Canadian True Crime” is an engaging and meticulous exploration of criminal cases hosted by Kristi Lee. Focusing exclusively on Canadian stories, Lee delves into a variety of cases, from historical mysteries to contemporary crimes. With a respectful and thorough approach, the podcast provides a captivating narrative that not only examines the criminal acts but also delves into the broader societal context. For true crime enthusiasts seeking a diverse and in-depth examination of Canadian criminal history, this podcast delivers compelling storytelling.

Hollywood and Crime

“Hollywood and Crime” takes listeners on a captivating journey through the dark underbelly of Hollywood’s criminal history, hosted by Tracy Pattin. The podcast expertly weaves together true crime stories from the glamourous era of Tinseltown, offering a fascinating look at infamous cases. With meticulous research and immersive storytelling, Pattin exposes the shocking crimes that lurked behind the glitz and glamour. For true crime enthusiasts intrigued by the intersection of fame and criminality, this podcast provides a compelling and insightful exploration.

The Mind of a Monster

“The Mind of a Monster” provides a chilling exploration into the psyches of infamous criminals, hosted by Dr. Jessica Taylor. With a background in forensic psychology, Taylor delivers insightful analyses of the motivations and behaviors of serial killers and other perpetrators. The podcast combines in-depth research with expert commentary, offering a nuanced perspective on the darkest corners of the human mind. For true crime enthusiasts fascinated by the psychological aspects of criminal behavior, this podcast delivers a captivating and educational experience.

Missing & Murdered

More heinous crimes north of the border… awful.

“Missing and Murdered” is a poignant true crime podcast hosted by Connie Walker, focused on the stories of missing and murdered Indigenous women in Canada. With compassion and investigative prowess, Walker sheds light on cases that often go overlooked. The podcast delves into the complexities of these cases while exploring broader issues of systemic injustice. For true crime enthusiasts seeking not only compelling narratives but also a socially conscious perspective, “Missing and Murdered” offers an eye-opening and emotionally resonant listening experience.

The Dark Histories Podcast

“The Dark Histories Podcast” is an enthralling exploration of historical true crime and mysteries, hosted by Ben Cutmore. Combining meticulous research with a captivating storytelling style, Cutmore delves into lesser-known cases from the past, shedding light on forgotten stories. For true crime enthusiasts intrigued by the dark corners of history, this podcast provides a deep and insightful examination of mysteries that have slipped through the cracks of mainstream attention, offering a unique and compelling listening experience.

True Crime Obsessed

“True Crime Obsessed” is a delightful blend of true crime commentary and comedy, hosted by Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle. With humor, wit, and a touch of sarcasm, the hosts offer entertaining recaps and discussions of true crime documentaries and shows. Their engaging banter makes even the darkest cases more approachable, creating a unique and enjoyable listening experience. For true crime enthusiasts who appreciate a lighthearted take on gripping narratives, “True Crime Obsessed” delivers an entertaining and amusing perspective.

Unravel True Crime

“Unravel True Crime” is an Australian true crime podcast hosted by various presenters exploring intriguing and often lesser-known criminal cases. With meticulous research and compelling storytelling, each season delves into a different aspect of crime, offering unique perspectives on notorious cases. For true crime enthusiasts seeking international narratives and a thoughtful examination of the criminal justice system, “Unravel True Crime” provides an immersive and informative listening experience that spans a diverse range of captivating stories.

Wine & Crime

“Wine & Crime” is a true crime podcast with a refreshing twist, hosted by Kenyon, Lucy, and Amanda. The hosts pair true crime stories with wine, creating a unique and entertaining listening experience. The podcast combines humor and insightful commentary, making even the darkest cases more approachable. For true crime enthusiasts looking for a laid-back and enjoyable exploration of criminal stories, “Wine & Crime” offers a delightful blend of comedy, camaraderie, and intriguing narratives.

Obscura: A True Crime Podcast

“Obscura: A True Crime Podcast” distinguishes itself with a meticulous and respectful exploration of lesser-known true crime cases, hosted by Justin Drown. The podcast delves into the details of both solved and unsolved crimes, providing a thoughtful examination of criminal psychology and justice. For true crime enthusiasts who appreciate in-depth research and a focus on storytelling, “Obscura” offers a compelling and informative journey into the darker corners of the criminal world with a sincere dedication to the victims.

The Dark Side Of…

“The Dark Side Of” is an engrossing true crime podcast hosted by Jack Luna that delves into the sinister aspects of various topics, from famous personalities to cultural phenomena. Luna’s captivating storytelling and thorough research reveal the dark underbelly of each subject, offering a fresh perspective on true crime. For enthusiasts seeking a diverse range of intriguing narratives beyond traditional criminal cases, “The Dark Side Of” provides an immersive and thought-provoking exploration into the shadowy realms of the human experience.

Crime Beat

“Crime Beat” stands out as an engrossing true crime podcast, hosted by Nancy Hixt, where each episode meticulously dissects compelling criminal cases. Hixt, a seasoned crime reporter, brings a journalist’s perspective and empathetic storytelling to the forefront. The podcast covers a variety of cases, combining expert analysis with victim-centric narratives. For true crime enthusiasts looking for comprehensive investigations and a deep understanding of the human impact of crime, “Crime Beat” offers a compelling and informative listening experience.

The Murder Tapes

“The Murder Tapes” delivers an intense and raw true crime experience, presenting real-life homicide investigations through authentic police footage and audio recordings. The podcast offers a chilling glimpse into crime scenes, interrogations, and detective work, providing an immersive and unfiltered perspective on criminal cases. For true crime enthusiasts seeking a gripping and unscripted exploration of the investigative process, “The Murder Tapes” offers a unique and compelling dive into the visceral reality of homicide investigations.

True Crime Island

“True Crime Island” is a captivating true crime podcast hosted by Cambo, providing a distinctive Australian perspective on criminal cases. Cambo’s laid-back and humorous style adds a unique flair to each episode, covering a wide range of intriguing cases. The podcast offers in-depth research and commentary, creating an engaging and informative experience for true crime enthusiasts. For those interested in exploring true crime narratives with an Australian focus and a touch of humor, “True Crime Island” is a delightful and compelling choice.

True Crime All The Time

“True Crime All The Time” stands out in the true crime podcast genre with hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson, who bring a perfect blend of humor and seriousness to their discussions. The podcast covers a wide range of cases, offering thorough research and engaging storytelling. With an approachable tone and a mix of well-known and lesser-known cases, it provides a comprehensive and entertaining experience for true crime enthusiasts who appreciate a balanced and accessible exploration of criminal stories.

Thinking Sideways

“Thinking Sideways” was a unique true crime podcast hosted by Joe, Steve, and Devin, exploring mysterious and unsolved cases, from paranormal occurrences to true crime mysteries. The hosts’ chemistry and casual banter made complex cases approachable and entertaining. The podcast, now concluded, offers a diverse array of intriguing narratives, making it an excellent choice for true crime enthusiasts seeking a mix of compelling storytelling and lively discussions on enigmatic and puzzling cases.

As an update, it turns out that the podcast may, in fact, not be concluded. It seems they did take a hiatus and “drop off the face of the planet,” but now seem to be making episodes again. That could be very exciting. Watch this space.

Small Town Murder

“Small Town Murder” is an enthralling true crime comedy podcast hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman. Combining humor with meticulous research, the duo explores murder cases in small towns, offering a unique perspective on criminal stories often overshadowed by larger city cases. The hosts strike a balance between informative storytelling and comedic commentary, creating an engaging and accessible experience for true crime enthusiasts who appreciate a lighthearted yet respectful approach to even the darkest subjects in the genre.

Criminology

“Criminology” is a compelling true crime podcast hosted by Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford, diving deep into unsolved mysteries and cold cases. The hosts combine meticulous research with immersive storytelling, exploring the intricacies of criminal investigations. With a focus on lesser-known cases and a respectful approach to victims, the podcast offers a thought-provoking journey into the world of crime-solving. For true crime enthusiasts seeking a comprehensive examination of unsolved mysteries, “Criminology” provides an engaging and informative listening experience.

Unexplained

“Unexplained” is a mesmerizing true crime podcast hosted by Richard MacLean Smith, exploring the enigmatic and supernatural. With a narrative style reminiscent of classic ghost stories, the podcast investigates mysterious phenomena, unsolved mysteries, and eerie occurrences. Smith’s eloquent storytelling and careful research create a captivating atmosphere, providing a thought-provoking blend of true crime and the unexplained. For true crime enthusiasts intrigued by the mysterious and paranormal, “Unexplained” offers a compelling journey into the realms of the unknown.

Case Remains

“Case Remains” is a riveting true crime podcast hosted by Beth, unraveling unsolved mysteries and true crime cases. With meticulous research and a respectful approach to victims, Beth delves into the details of each case, shedding light on lesser-known stories. The podcast combines compelling storytelling with a focus on unresolved mysteries, providing an immersive and thoughtful exploration into the intricacies of criminal investigations. For true crime enthusiasts seeking in-depth analyses and lesser-known cases, “Case Remains” offers a captivating and informative listening experience.

Killafornia Dreaming

“Killafornia Dreaming” is an engrossing true crime podcast hosted by Roseanne, delving into California-based criminal cases. With a unique narrative style and meticulous research, Roseanne brings lesser-known stories to the forefront, offering an immersive exploration of the state’s dark underbelly. The podcast combines storytelling with in-depth analysis, shedding light on the complexities of each case. For true crime enthusiasts seeking a regional focus on California’s intriguing and diverse criminal history, “Killafornia Dreaming” provides a captivating listening experience.

True Crime Historian

“True Crime Historian” is a captivating podcast hosted by Richard O Jones, offering a unique blend of historical true crime tales. With meticulous research and an engaging storytelling style, Jones resurrects forgotten criminal cases from the past. The podcast not only explores the crimes but also delves into the societal context and cultural nuances of each era, providing a thought-provoking and educational experience. For true crime enthusiasts interested in historical perspectives, “True Crime Historian” delivers a compelling and informative journey through time.

They Walk Among Us

“They Walk Among Us” is a compelling true crime podcast hosted by Benjamin and Rosanna Fitton, unraveling criminal cases from the UK. With a focus on meticulous research and a restrained narrative style, the hosts provide an in-depth exploration of notorious and lesser-known cases. The podcast offers a chilling glimpse into the minds of criminals and the complexities of the British justice system, making it an essential listen for true crime enthusiasts seeking well-researched and immersive storytelling.

The Dropout

“The Dropout” chronicles the captivating rise and fall of Elizabeth Holmes, founder of Theranos. Hosted by Rebecca Jarvis, this investigative podcast unveils the complexities of fraud, corporate deception, and the mysterious allure surrounding Silicon Valley startups. A riveting exploration for true crime enthusiasts fascinated by white-collar crime and scandalous business practices.

Southern Fried True Crime

Delve into the dark side of the Southern United States with “Southern Fried True Crime.” Host Erica Kelley provides in-depth analyses of chilling crimes, mysterious deaths, and unsolved murders, capturing the essence of Southern gothic storytelling. Ideal for true crime enthusiasts seeking a regional focus on crime narratives amid the backdrop of the American South.

White Lies

“White Lies” unravels the unsolved murder of Reverend James Reeb during the civil rights era. Hosted by Chip Brantley and Andrew Beck Grace, this podcast investigates the layers of racial tension, conspiracy, and the quest for justice. A thought-provoking exploration for true crime enthusiasts intrigued by historical mysteries and the complexities of racial struggles.

Your Own Backyard

“Your Own Backyard” investigates the mysterious disappearance of Kristin Smart, a college student who vanished in California in 1996. Host Chris Lambert meticulously explores the case, shedding light on new evidence and unearthing long-buried secrets. An engaging listen for true crime enthusiasts fascinated by cold cases and the relentless pursuit of truth.

Bear Brook

“Bear Brook” unfolds a chilling tale of unidentified bodies found in barrels in New Hampshire’s Bear Brook State Park. Hosted by Jason Moon, the podcast navigates forensic mysteries, familial DNA, and the quest to solve a decades-old mystery. A must-listen for true crime enthusiasts intrigued by forensic advancements and the pursuit of justice in cold cases.

Death in Ice Valley

“Death in Ice Valley” ventures into a mysterious death in Norway’s Isdalen Valley. Hosted by Marit Higraff and Neil McCarthy, this investigative podcast explores espionage, mysterious identities, and the intricate web surrounding an unidentified woman’s demise. Perfect for true crime enthusiasts intrigued by international mysteries and historical intrigue.

Slow Burn

“Slow Burn” explores pivotal moments in American political history. Hosted by Leon Neyfakh, each season provides a deep dive into notorious events, including Watergate and the Clinton impeachment. A compelling choice for true crime enthusiasts interested in the political landscape and the mysterious intricacies of past scandals.

Court Junkie

“Court Junkie” with host Jillian Jalali offers an in-depth look at courtroom dramas, legal battles, and true crime cases. With meticulous research and insightful commentary, the podcast provides an engaging perspective on the criminal justice system. A perfect fit for true crime enthusiasts seeking a comprehensive and analytical exploration of high-profile court cases.

FAQs: True Crime Podcasts

Q: What is the number 1 true crime podcast?

A: The landscape of true crime podcasts is dynamic, with rankings often changing. However, popular choices include “Serial,” “My Favorite Murder,” and “Criminal,” each offering a unique perspective on gripping real-life stories.

Q: What is the #1 rated true crime podcast on Spotify?

A: Spotify’s rankings may fluctuate, but podcasts like “Crime Junkie,” “Sword and Scale,” and “Casefile” have consistently garnered high ratings from listeners seeking compelling true crime narratives.

Q: What is the true crime podcast told as a story?

A: “Serial” is renowned for its narrative storytelling approach, unraveling complex true crime cases in a compelling and sequential manner.

Q: What are some good true crime podcast recommendations?

A: Aside from the mentioned podcasts, consider exploring “The Last Podcast On The Left,” “Criminal Minds,” and “True Crime Garage” for diverse and engaging true crime content.

Q: What are the best True Crime podcasts to listen to during commutes?

A: Opt for shorter episodes or serialized formats like “Criminal,” “Sword and Scale,” or “Crime Junkie” to make the most of your commute with captivating true crime stories.

Q: Are spoilers still spoilers if it’s real life?

A: While real-life events are technically known, the storytelling nuances and details can still be surprising and suspenseful, making the term “spoiler” subjective in the context of true crime podcasts.

Q: Which true crime podcast has the most episodes?

A: “Casefile” is known for its extensive collection of episodes, providing in-depth coverage of various true crime cases.

Q: Which true crime podcasts have the most captivating storytelling?

A: Podcasts like “Lore,” “Criminal,” and “My Favorite Murder” are praised for their captivating storytelling, combining suspense, research, and immersive narration.

Q: What are the top 10 true crime podcasts currently trending?

A: Trends evolve, but “The Daily,” “Crime Junkie,” “Sword and Scale,” and “Last Podcast On The Left” were among the top true crime podcasts trending on various platforms.

The post The 61 Best True Crime Podcasts of All Time appeared first on Discover the Best Podcasts | Discover Pods.

(Editor’s note: This piece is being published anonymously to avoid harassment from the My Favorite Murder fanbase, aka “murderinos.” I’m also not including a listen link for the podcast, because I do not want to.)

True crime and My Favorite Murder

Before we dive into what is sure to be a lively debate about what is or isn’t sexist when critiquing work by women, let’s take a moment to set some boundaries: This piece is not about the genre of true crime podcasts as a whole. The ins and outs of whether it is informative or exploitative to spin entertainment out of real world events and tragedies is a complicated one, and frankly as old as storytelling itself, so it’s not getting solved here. Neither is this a critique of Kilgariff and Hardstark for starting the podcast in the first place. They offered the show up, and audiences chose to listen of their own free will, and two women succeeding at a podcast is not what we’re here to critique.

Read more: I Am Tired of True Crime

What we are here to critique is the personal spin, and the personal biases, presented within any episode of My Favorite Murder. Since the show’s beginning in 2016, American comedians Kilgariff and Hardstark have been bringing weekly episodes in which they each present the story of a real life murder, recapping the events to one-another and sharing commentary as the stories unfold. These murders can be high profile deaths and killers like Aileen Wuornos or the The Who concert disaster of December 3rd, 1979, or less well known stories that a host did more extensive research on.

White women tears

After years of doing these weekly reports (and a second mini-sode each week wherein they read fan messages and fan “hometown murder” stories, which we’ll discuss later), the hosts have defined their reason for doing this show as being a sort of coping mechanism. “This is a dealing with our anxiety podcast, and don’t you fucking judge us for dealing with our anxiety,” said Hardstark at a live show in Dublin 2018. Kilgariff, at the same show, said, “If this is something you might have a problem with, we invite you to fuck off right now.”  While coping mechanisms and supportive mental health communities are 100% important, and Kilgariff and Hardstark do deserve commendation for being upfront and honest about their mental health experience, once can’t help but notice a slight disconnect, and a rushing to play the victim, especially in Kilgariff’s words. Warning audiences about the content of an upcoming show is one thing, telling them to “fuck off right now” (and being answered by thunderous applause) is a different matter entirely. 

My Favorite Murder has sold true crime obsession as some sort of necessary coping mechanism to its fans, some kind of emergency vent that has to be opened for any sane listener. This is, again, a broader psychological question, whether humans crave and need violent stories or not. However, we can say for certain that most people’s means of coping with anxiety isn’t spun into a lucrative podcasting network with merchandise, live shows, and a book deal. Furthermore, the fact that they feel the need to preemptively condemn anyone who would “judge” (read: critique) the hosts indicates the hosts’ refusal to interrogate their own platform, and the messages they may be spreading with it. 

Speaking of the messages they’re spreading, Kilgariff and Hardstark frequently encourage their listeners (predominantly white women) to call the cops whenever they feel vaguely threatened (under the motto of “fuck politeness,” an ethos that feels empowering in a 2nd wave feminist way at best, and a tool of White Feminist self-empowerment at worst). Considering the copious cell phone footage that’s been captured of white women harassing nonwhite people for having the audacity to exist in spaces that white people feel entitled to as their own, it doesn’t take long to imagine the dangers of self-important white women saying “fuck politeness” before calling the cops on the “suspicious” black guy walking around their neighborhood. 

Granted, there is the context of sexual violence to consider. Women do run a higher risk of being murdered by a partner or ex, and domestic violence is absolutely a continuous and rampant problem in this country. Trans people likewise face extremely higher likelihood of being murdered or violently assaulted, as do queer people. As do black people, or Asians, following a year of xenophobic hate.

The problem is, Kilgariff and Hardstark aren’t talking about all of these other identities. They’re talking to their audience about situations where you might just feel “skeeved out” by a stranger. And as this country has proven, American white women (the majority of MFM’s fanbase) tend to feel “skeeved out” by people who don’t look like them.

Read more: “Asking for It” Wants Honesty about Queer Domestic Violence

My Favorite Murder is copaganda

In telling their stories, they also frequently laud police with little acknowledgment of police brutality or corruption, or the ways cops are less likely to investigate the murders of non-white, non-straight, non-cis, non-middle-to-upper class victims. What the hosts claim to be an inclusive, communal look into the most horrid crimes is actually, in practice, an example of implicit bias and blindspots run rampant.

Even in stories they discuss that do highlight police negligence, Hardstark and Kilgariff are quick to either move past police misuse of power, or treat these incidents like a total outlier as opposed to actual demonstrable patterns of police abusing their power. For all of the hundreds of murdered they’ve covered, the hosts of My Favorite Murder are always hesitant to point out larger systemic patterns of neglect and abuse. Or perhaps they’re not hesitant to do this; rather, they’re just not interested in it. That’s now what the show is about, after all — My Favorite Murder is not about the systems at play that allow Jeffrey Dahmer to keep killing after police return an escaped victim back to him, it’s just about some pals talking about murder.

Beyond giving police corruption a blind eye, Kilgariff and Hardstark have even indulged in full-on hero worship of police, the most outstanding example being their adulation of Paul Holes. To his credit, Holes was instrumental in finally solving the Golden State Killer case in 2018 (It should be noted that the Golden State Killer, Joseph James DeAngelo, was also a former police officer as well). Kilgariff and Hardstark were  huge fans of Holes, contributing to a swell in popularity that made Holes a minor celebrity in true crimes corners of the internet in 2018. 

Whiles Holes deserves commendation for helping catch a killer that had been active for four decades, he also functioned within the larger system of American police until his retirement in 2018. However, after his retirement, Holes and journalist Billy Jensen now run the podcast The Murder Squad, where the two discuss unsolved cases and, crucially, solicit investigative help from listeners. This urge to make vigilantes and armchair analysts out of listeners might come from a sincere place, but it does open the show, and the investigators, up to listeners’ own untrained accusations and implicit biases, something the American justice system has enough of already. The Murder Squad is not the same as My Favorite Murder, though it is hosted Kilgariff and Hardstark’s Exactly Right podcast network.

Live episodes of My Favorite Murder also contain their fair share of biases and curious framing of events. As Kilgariff and Hardstark tell their respective stories, audiences will cheer whenever a host mentions a convictions— even when hosts then reveal the person in the story arrested was, in fact, innocent. There’s an auditory bloodlust in these applause — the story is no longer about what happened to the victim, but about what happened to the killer, and the audience is hungry for blood.

Audiences frequently applaud the death penalty when it comes up in the hosts’ stories, which summarizes the atmosphere. Thinking back to the hosts’ comments in Dublin, does this sound like a nice coping mechanism? Or does it sound like what it really is, a live comedy show built around real life tragedies?

The MFM merchandising complicates these blends of vicarious interest and something darker even more. “Fuck Politeness,” as  a slogan, is a sort of ethos for the fans (amusingly called “Murderinos,” which is just fun), and also appearing on official MFM merchandise. Further, the show’s official fan group is called ‘The Fan Cult,’ which is on one hand a clearly ironic title, but on the other a casual mocking of people who have been or know people who have been harmed by being caught up in extremist cults.

Promoting a parasocial fanbase

Let’s return to the concept of “Hometowns” — wherein the hosts of MFM encourage listeners to submit own true crime stories from their lives — all well and good, the listeners are consenting adults, they choose to share their stories, but the whole arrangement does have an unsettling parasocial undercurrent: If you want to get in the club, if you want to hear your good friends Karen and Georgia, who share your anxiety, who give you your coping mechanism, you’ll tell them about something violent. Don’t you want to be a real part of the MFM story? To quote another serial killing entertainment icon, “Quid pro quo, yes or no, Clarice?”

Then there’s the show’s closing segment, called “Fuckin’ Hurray,” where Kilgariff and Hardstark close the show with something positive in their lives. Ending their show on a lighter note is a reasonable call, except “Fuckin’ Hurray” is a false equivalency. It seems to put forward the idea that minor pleasures can counteract the loss of life and systemic violence. Yes, Jonbenet Ramsey died at age 6, but on the other hand, have you seen The Alienist?

Stay sexy and don’t get murdered

Finally, looming over all of the other catchphrases and segments is MFM’s main manta: “Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered.” It’s catchy, but it’s also a phrase that casually places the onus of safety onto victims. Neither this or the false equivalence of “Fuckin’ Hurray” are likely intentional in their ramifications, nor did Kilgariff and Hardstark likely intend to define them in these terms. But that’s kind of the point. Whether the hosts intended these meanings or not is irrelevant. The words do it on their own.

That’s the issue with My Favorite Murder overall: It isn’t that they are intentionally white-supremacist copaganda-spreaders looking to indoctrinate their fans. They aren’t, at least not intentionally. What they are is two white women in a prominent entertainment position, occupying a position of power and privilege. They are funny performers, and savvy entertainers, and likely do have their hearts in the right place. When they throw stones, they likely aren’t aiming for anyone’s head. But whatever they intended to hit, wherever they intended the stones to land, the ripples they cast exist all the same.

My Favorite Murder is a show that knows not what it does, but that’s not actually an excuse. The hosts of My Favorite Murder can encourage us to “Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered” all they like, but for themselves, they might consider a more direct slogan: “Do Better.”

The post Why Your Podcast Sucks: My Favorite Murder’s Real Favorite Is the Cops appeared first on Discover the Best Podcasts | Discover Pods.

Pods Review Pods is a weekly segment where podcasters review fellow podcasts.

My name is Tiffany John. I’m a writer, graphic artist, and one of the three hosts of Pondo’s Playground. Our subjects focus primarily on the vast art of storytelling across multiple mediums—think books, games, movies, comics—and are fueled by our love of good stories. No character journey is off limits. The first few weeks of every month, we discuss a genre or story subject, and during the final week we experiment and produce an original dramatic short story reading.

Pondo’s Playground is available on Stitcher, Soundcloud, and other popular podcast apps.

Facebook/Twitter

The Sell More Books Show

This podcast is a godsend for indie authors and publishers. Jim and Bryan share tips, up to date news and best practices for those looking to succeed in book publishing. I love the simple format they’ve put together and how everything is broken down into digestible pieces of information. They present things so that listeners are easily able to implement their tools for book marketing.

Listen: Stitcher | Apple Podcasts

My Favorite Murder

My Favorite Murder is a comedy true crime podcast hosted by Georgia Hardstark and Karen Kilgariff. Comedy and true crime don’t seem like a good fit, but these ladies make it work. Each week the two come together, along with their producer Stephen, to share carefully selected true crime stories. These stories are presented in a comfortable and accessible way, allowing them to share the lessons that come from tragedy. From listening I have to learned to stay out of the forest, f*ck politeness, call my dad if I end up in a cult and most importantly to stay sexy and don’t get murdered.

Listen: Stitcher | Apple Podcasts

Can I Pet Your Dog?

This is a must for dog lovers. Renee and Allegra host this dog-centric  podcast that allows those of us without dogs to embrace our love for them. The shoe features dogs the hosts have met, special celebrity guests (the first episode had  Lin-Manuel Miranda!), and tips for dog owners. I love the simplicity of this podcast and how it has made dog education entertaining and fun.

Listen: Apple Podcasts | Stitcher

The post Pods Review Pods: The Sell More Books Show, My Favorite Murder, & Can I Pet Your Dog? appeared first on Discover the Best Podcasts | Discover Pods.

Though relatively harmless and not all that memorable, this line from 2014 reshaped entertainment media and thrust podcasts into the popular mainstream. It’s no “call me Ishmael”, but neither This American Life, Sarah Koenig, the rest of the Serial staff, nor hundreds of thousands of people who initially heard this line realized at the time the importance of what they were experiencing. Before Serial, only 27% of the US had listened to a podcast.

Podcasts became a thing. At least for the time being.

Podcasts existed and were popular with a segment of the population well before Serial launched, but now they were a thing in a more grandiose manner. For the first time, podcasts were part of the monoculture. There was even an SNL skit parodying Serial.

See the Serial spike in search volume in late 2014.

Serial was a true crime podcast analyzing the possible crime, but definite conviction, of Adnan Syed who was accused of killing his girlfriend in 2010. He was issued life in prison without the possibility of parole. Due to the ambiguity in the case, many unanswered questions, and apparently enough reasonable doubt the podcast producers deemed his story compelling enough to be made into a 12-episode podcast.

The monoculture Serial created hasn’t quite been replicated since. The second installment of Serial was popular, but not to the same extent. So was 2017’s hit from the same studio, S-Town. But still not quite the same. Instead, imitators emerged trying to resurrect Serial’s success. Though no podcast succeeded with this mission, the combined force of true crime podcasts came to define the podcast medium as a whole. True crime podcasts reign supreme. Look at the Apple Podcast charts on any given day and you’ll likely see a few inside the top 10.

Currently, Atlanta Monster is the true crime du jour. Before that it was Dirty John. Before that it was S-Town. Before that it was Up and Vanished. You also have the episodic true crime podcasts like Criminal, My Favorite Murder, and others constantly producing podcasts and compelling stories, subsequently keeping the true crime genre top of mind.

How did we get here though? Serial was supposed to propel all podcasts to the mainstream, not just true crime.

Though it’s tough to quantify how this happened, we have qualitative examples of how this happened with other mediums. The easiest proxy is to compare HBO’s The Jinx, and Netflix’s Making a Murderer — two true crime documentary series that in their respective moments entered the monoculture and became watercooler conversation.

For all their marketing firepower, HBO and Netflix have also become incredible engines propagating word of mouth recommendations. Think back to when you first viewed one of those series, chances are your interest was piqued with someone asking “Have you seen The Jinx yet?!” Despite being major names with literally millions of subscribers, both networks still rely on inter-personal recommendations that an algorithm can’t quite reproduce. For whatever reason, true crime lends itself the best to stoking word of mouth recommendations. Maybe it’s people’s desires to talk about their thoughts on the case. Or maybe it’s that weird unspoken social currency of knowing the ending before someone else. Either way, the true crime genre is somehow manufactured to encourage people to share it with others.

The last few years the general public has said “there’s too much tv” and on any given week there are new shows from HBO, Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, ABC, NBC, CBS, Fox, FX, Starz, Showtime, Bravo, Comedy Central and a couple other channels you’d like to try out. Actual dozens of new shows you’d like to watch.

Podcasts take this example to the extreme. By most estimates, we’re approaching 500,000 podcasts, and they’re still growing extremely fast. It’s impossible to keep up with all the new podcasts, and because there’s no real discovery mechanism to find new podcasts, word of mouth remains the main driver for new listeners.

While Serial was looked at as propping up podcasts as a whole, instead it became the first real example of how much a podcast’s success is dependent word of mouth recommendations. Though this is largely still the case, there are now more quality true crime examples to diversify the listener base and the fragmentation has quelled any more monoculture podcasts from entering the mainstream limelight.

Podcasts, at least for now, remain a true crime-dominant medium.

The post The Serial Effect: How True Crime Came to Dominate Podcasts appeared first on Discover the Best Podcasts | Discover Pods.